It is a drag and also rather more attention getting than is desirable, since I generally have to hike up my skirt to unhook it. The B72--the saddle that came with many English three-speeds--offers a somewhat cushier ride than a B17 but not quite as boingy as the B66 or B67. I might take a coat to a tailor and have a zipper sewn into the rear. The pebbled texture keeps me from sliding around. Justine: "I think I made the point you also made"Yes, I simply generalized it a bit to include frame geometry. Only the finest premium vegetable tanned leather for strength, beauty and durability. By the way there just has to be a mecca around the NW somewhere. Spam will not be approved. And the rounded edges make it easier to slide off the bicycle when dismounting - which is convenient when making frequent stops in the city. and various bikes (the low point was a bike with rear suspension). Well, this post is five years late, but my mother suggested I use a rolling pin (as in baking) and roll my Brooks every night while watching TV, to break it in. Hi I'm enjoying your Blog immenselyI've had a number of different Brooks over the years on different bikes, wide, narrow, sprung and unsprung. I've ridden the B67 and B72, as well as the Ideale 6, which was similar to the Brooks B72. In comparison to the B66, the B72 seems like a more versatile saddle to me. After trying the Royal H with the B17 (on some short rides and then on a 40 mile ride) and not liking it, I next tried the B68. There are many who feel that flyer and … This clamp has a diameter of 22.2 mm or 7/8'' and is compatible with all Brooks double rail models (B18, B66, B66S, B72, B73, B135, B190) … Townmouse: You're right about "breaking in" Brooks saddles. A good cycling bike position should always aim to balance the weight between the contact points, the hands, bottom and less so the feet.The second thing I'd like to say is that the narrowness of the saddle depends on how far far forward you have to lean to reach the handlebars as well the steepness of the seat tube. I'd venture to say the equator line of your saddle being level with the bars is the limit for say a B17 (above or level) or a Team Pro (below).To me springs only seem to make sense if you're putting a lot of weight on them i.e. Think inside the box. This has the Selle Royal which does lead to a bit of saddle-soreness. It seems to take a bit longer to break in. Haven't really solved that one yet except to do a slightly embarrassing scoop dance to get back on the seat. I do not place paid promotional content within blog posts. I've had the B67 for 12 years now - as strong as new - this has enabled me to start cycling 'normally' culminating in a two week, 50 mile a day tour through Northern France (Normandy/Brittany) with a cycling buddy.The (my) Medical opinionThe Brooks has moulded to the shape of my arse (or 'sit bones'). It felt much more comfortable than the B17, but "weird"; just didn't seem to feel right with the bike. But I had an older B72 on my mixte, and it was the most painful thing for me! kfg - You hit the nail on the head and described what I had meant to express in the "Men's vs Women's" paragraph, but ran out of brain energy & time. They are otherwise deaf and blind. To help I'd tried various saddles (wide/narrow/sprung/ergo?) I don't really have a good explanation as to why; it's just a subjective feeling of appropriateness. LOL.I think I made the point you also made: that the "men's" and "women's" labels in saddles are meaningless. Hopefully my saddle bag will solve that possible issue.Bif - Indeed the B135 does touch on the Steampunk aesthetic. The Bag Balm soften the leather so much I had to crank two turns on the under-nut to tighten the leather. I have treated it with Proofide and that softened it up a bit, but it is still not broken in. Threespeeder - The B67S is the same width as the B67 non-S (210mm), so that won't help. The other semi-related problem that I've had is that whenever I wear pants that have back pockets, the pocket always gets caught on the nose of the saddle whenever I hop up on it. I have a B72 mounted on my Pashley Roadster - without a "seat sandwich" - and now that I know what they actually are and what they do - I will be replacing my seatpost with a micro-adjust ASAP.The splines that locate the angle of the B72 are in what feel like 6 degree increments - a HUGE difference, for my anatomy, from one position to the other.Other than this small inconvenience, I LOVE this saddle on this bike. . That's quality and durability! Would be a mess to ruin them. I always thought I was cursed with being too sensitive in the you-know-where, but now I know that even a sore posterior can find relief! ;-). The kind I'm wearing too. To those who own saddles narrower than B17 and find them comfortable: thanks for your comments and I am completely open to different opinions on this. You are a quick learner! Not head-down grinding and not sit-up-read-the-newspaper, or at least this is how I visualise it...). That is important to note. Now we can make a much more informed decision. Corey K. As far as angle goes, I like to tilt the noses on my upright saddles up quite a bit, or else I slide forward. Although why different saddles take different lengths of time to break in, I don't know. When I was in high school, I started racing in our local competitions. Made in England. In 1888, Brooks England began making leather saddles. I have a 30 year old Brooks B72 saddle on my Raleigh Sports (the original saddle from 1968) and I love it. Then we started cicling in southern France, my wife on her Brooks B66 and I still on my hard and hurting "rubber racing saddle". Many men have wide sit bones; many women have narrow. Brooks B66 Vs B67 – Compare for You. I am building a bike for a friend of mine and we have been going back and forth about this. i suppose if you were racing, or a lot heavier (i'm 6' and 165 lb), i might feel some lateral movement, but for the few times i've ridden my wife's bike, i've enjoyed the saddle. Compounding that is that you are saying the Swallow is too narrow for the non-aggressive riding that I do, but it is still wider than the Selle Italia SLR that I am currently using and am content with. SEE SLENDER GRIPS. So when I got this one today in the post I saw it was an "S" model. The B66S on my Pashley broke in after 2 weeks. So if I am out for a long day, I have padded under shorts that a nice full skirt hides very well : ) I don't think it is the saddles, I think it is just me.The "S" feature for me helps in one area- when I am mounting the saddle while starting, standard length saddles always grab my waist band or back pockets and that drives me nuts!! And if it takes a big man to cry, I would say it takes an even bigger man to bottom out the springs on a B135. Dire que la marque anglaise Brooks figure dans la légende du cyclisme est à peine exagéré. Pardon the puns. Although I think most would challenge it as a "practical" bike I think most ex-racers/messengers would find it delightfully so. The flyer is great on london streets (potholes and cobbles and patchwork ads) where shock absorbtion without excessive bounce really comes into its own. Certaines selles Brooks comme les B67, Flyer, B17 se décline en version classique ou en version S (par exemple B67 et B67S). It doesn't happen with swingier clothes but does with pencil minis and a-lines. (I still can't sew worth a damn!) New ones, such as are still available, will be found on an old shelf, in an old store room, in an old bike store, covered with old dust, somewhere in the midwest.The NW is where demand for such bikes is highest, so where availability is lowest and prices highest. Last year I bought a slightly used Salsa Vaya whose owner had installed a basic B17. A comfy saddle really is crucial when bicycle touring, don’t opt for the gel alternatives and instead commit to a saddle that properly supports your “Sit bones” and lasts forever. "That's the path that eventually led me to a Quickbeam. This site is a free online resource that strives to offer helpful content and comparison features to its visitors. :), your site has lots of informations for us kind of peoples thanks for sharing this in internet.. Sure will return for an update.. http://ww.dmaxonline.com. . The only way I've been able to solve this, was to not wear clothes that cause this problem. Quality control is high. Perhaps we are the minority, but I disagree that one should assume such a shape will necessarily be uncomfortable just by probability!! About how long did you find it took for the saddle to wear in? The B67 is slightly narrower and works perfectly or me. Dion Lewis. Very informative and well thought out post on Brooks saddles. Stainless steel frames are gorgeous, perhaps a little too much so for me. It is amazing that you know so much about bicycles and yet you only began riding in the Spring of '08. Can anyone comment on why that might be and whether it has any pros or cons? I've been going back and forth on getting a Brooks and then on which one to get. I know this is years too late, but don't put a zipper in the back of your coat where it will scuff both you and your beloved saddle. When you were building up the Royal H., you asked for advice about which saddle to put on it. "The latest trend is for marketing geniuses to troll the internets. I eventually when with the B66S and have no regrets. The B72 was standard issue on classic Raleigh Sports 3-speed bicycles. So I wonder if it was an aesthetic decision for them as much as or more than a budget one. Nina - I've had that problem too! That is very interesting the way you describe the different types of Brooks Saddle - I have just got the "Brompton" mens B17 Special saddle and it seems pretty good after the standard synthetic Brompton saddle. Advertiser Disclosure. In Iowa they're still just "that old bike in the barn. Width: 205 mm. "That would be in Iowa.Sorry I'm not being particularly helpful, but reality is like that sometimes. However I'd never been comfortable with rides of more than about 1 hour in the saddle (I'd get pain down my right leg). I agree with your comments, saddle choice is very dependent on riding style and position. Vite ! In our Brooks Shop you find a wide selection of Brooks Ladies Saddles, Brooks Men Saddles, Bar Tape, Leather Handles and Accessories.Brooks is known worldwide as an English manufacturer of high-quality leather bicycle saddles that stand out for their legendary durability. I just ordered the Flyer Select which I rode across the Country last year but gave the bike and saddle to my mom. I also find it extremely comfortable. I think I will try Neatsfoot Oil next. Would that they were also dumb (as opposed to stupid, which they are more often than not).See ( and hear) Bill Hicks. .if anyone could direct me to a Vintage/urban bike mecca in Portland OR or Seattle . Nearly 130 years later, the classic B17 Standard is among riders’ favorites for long distances. If you are satisfied with the narrow Selle Italia, Swallow should be right for you. "Instead, I'd keep it in the freezer in the garage. :). Bummer about the "availability" (although I believe a few of the smaller sizes might still be lying around Walnut Creek and Grant promises a similar bike in future). If I was to buy another I'd get the B67 single-rail which is compatible with micro adjust seatposts. "Maybe I will paste it into the main text as a quote from you if you do not mind. Flyer Imperial w/ Relief Cut-out In the 1890 Brooks catalogue, the oldest in the their archive, Brooks presents most of the saddles with the "registered cutting, a sure preventive to all perineal pressure". forrest lee: there's also a heavier sprung saddle that's not as wide as the B33, which is *huge*. I ride a Brooks B17 Classic on a daily basis. ).I haven’t an issue with a saddle carrying weight. Thank you, thank you, thank you! Two quick comments: women who plan to wear pants/shorts (not skirts) on their saddles should not get the S models because a longer nose provides both stability and a much bigger leather hammock to absorb shocks. What sort of bike is it? Brooks B17 vs Brooks Flyer; Product Comparison: Brooks B17 vs Brooks Flyer. Brooks Flyer Special Brown Black Rail Bicycle Saddle. Instead, I'd keep it in the freezer in the garage. I have a B66s on my Hercules, and LOVE it. Brooks England Brooks Bracket & Coil Assembly for Flyer, Flyer Special, B67 saddles. With this old, clapped-out, slightly-saggy and generally past-it's-sell-by-date saddle I found I could ride longer distances for the first time in my life without pain! Thanks again! Like many other commenters, I'm so grateful for these comparisons. S. On my commuter I ride Velo Orange "Milan" handlebars and the Gyes/Velo Orange "Parkside" saddle, which is similar to the Brooks B67--which is a B66 with a double-rail rather than a four-rail undercarriage. Both look gorgeous - the black flyer special on my lime blac edition brompton and the b67 select on my pashley aurora ( which is a fabulous ride with alfine 8 hub gears perfect for tackling everything the flat to Ditchling Beacon and Devils Dyke). I don't think I have gone that far yet. KFG: I fought long and hard for my right to ride a pink saddle with butterfly logos on it. From this I have a clear visual picture of where my previous cycling problems had come from. How about a kimchi pot buried in the yard? You should not need padded shorts on an upright bike if your saddle is right and proper. I want to retrofit four of my vintage bikes with better saddles and I've been at a loss to understand the different Brooks models. We have been using Mountain bikes, my wife is very comfortable with her Brooks B66 and afther having kept riding for too long on a "plastic-foam saddle", I have ordered (and receeved today) my Brooks B66. To ensure a comfortable atmosphere for my readers and myself, comments are moderated. Thank you for posting that article. are the same width as the standard versions. They're very helpful and they will allow you to exchange your saddle for another model--or to receive a refund--within six months of your purchase.Another suggestion: If you like a particular model, buy a spare, if you can afford it. JimP - Henry Cutler (WorkCycles) had a short discussion with "Feddo" about a stainless steel version of his Fr8 some time ago. To get a good sense of the differences in dimensions, I've compiled the specs from. I'd also like for it to have two rather than four rails, and for the top to have the same width as the B66/67 or Parkside. Anyone else have this problem and know if it's specific to the saddle?So far I've solved it with a coat that I can unzip a little from the bottom, essentially turning it into a short coat while I ride (also the world's most perfect bike coat in other ways - the Patagonia Tres Parka, I have no connection with Patagonia, just really in love with the way it solves so many problems of riding to work). I treat use proofhide on it at least once a week, or after it rains, i also have the cover which i use when the bike isnt used. However, if you don’t really need a suspension system, i.e. Durable Vegetable Tanned Leather. Racing was not the sport, it was more the silent and smooth displacement from the center of the city to the rural quiet of Holland in less than half a day. The saddle is durable, dries quickly, causes little to no chaffing and is incredibly comfortable. "From a Raleigh fork.". The substantial springs provide excellent cushiness when most of my weight rests on the saddle. relatively short rides of typically less than 10 or 12 miles around town. 5 out of 5 stars (4) Total Ratings 4, $136.88 New. I am always on the lookout for one. you are seeking a bike seat for touring and trekking, then Brooks B17 is the way for the fullest value for your money! I've learned so much about bikes from your blog! Cara - I tried the mixte with the B17 and it felt too narrow. Different cowhides have different stretch qualities.. Lots of good Brooks Saddle info when and if I am ever in the market for a new saddles. It has been properly treated with proof-hide and kneaded in. Just look at Selle Anatomica saddles for a comparison.And two: if you didn't already know--now you don't have to think that it's just you--anyone who buys a Brooks saddle better be prepared to tinker with it, adjust it endlessly, grease random parts to quiet the noises and otherwise obsess with the saddle for a LONG time, sometimes months after purchase until it is finally done and perfect. This was such a revelation I found out everything I could about Brooks saddles then splashed out on a fully-sprung double-rail B67. After 5 months the saddle has not yet broken in to be anywhere near as comfortable as the B67 on my Dutch bike, which broke in after a mere two weeks. Hello, I have not posted on this site before. Your experience with each saddle is invaluable towards my final decision. Strange it may seem that a city saddle first served a racing bike during some decades, then served a mountain bike for a decade and keeps absorbing the rough Catalonian countryroads and as a saddle does the work it is made for. Only problem I had was that the springs were very squeeky but that was solved by a spray of WD40. I ride only Brooks saddles: Professionals on my road bikes and a B67 on my upright bike. I do not participate in affiliate marketing. That's just one person's experience. Lots of knowledgeable collectors there; someone will know. Also I need some new brake cables. This is where other Brooks saddles can be really painful. Comment choisir sa selle Brooks ? Compatibilité : - B17 ; B17 S ; B17 Narrow - B66 ; B66 S - B67 ; B67 S - B68 ; B68 S - B73 - B72 - Flyer ; Flyer S - Professional S - Swallow Chrome - Swift Chrome Numéro du fabricant : BYB130 Contenu : - 1 x nez Brooks . After that, his Flyer went from rock-hard to perfect. It does not yet include many early and mid-20th century saddle models. townmouse - The Neatsfoot / no Neatsfoot issue is a grand debate when it comes to Brooks. Freezers are for vintage road bikes. "Not at all, although you may want to Strunk & Whiteize it a bit (use italics and/or bold where I have used non-HTML emphasis); or feel free to just rephrase it in your own words and style to spiff up what you've already written - my own infamy was secured long ago, so I have no issues with official credit.And as an aside I will take the opportunity to point out that if you poke around the web a bit you will find many WOMEN who are discontent with the fact that although a "women's specific" bike is what fits them, it is only available in a "Barbieized" version. Comfort is not always seated where you assume it is. My own view is that saddles narrower than B17 are not suitable for the majority of the non-pro, non-messenger population, and I stick to that despite variations in individual experience. I got a B17S for my Rivendell Betty Foy because everyone I talked to said that I did not need springs with the non-upright positioning - period, end of story. Clearly if you find the saddle comfortable, then it is the right saddle for you. Have a vent pleat put in, lined with some attractive fabric, and you will not have the problem of either catching yourself on the saddle or gouging everything with a zipper. This publication is sustained through sponsorship. In publication since 2009 Lovely Bicycle is an eclectic bicycling weblog featuring stories, reviews and miscellanea, with an emphasis on the classic and the handmade. Or longish coats long and hard for my mixte, and decided that I like! Just did n't seem to be seated upright but am looking for something a of... A spray of WD40 old style straight pipe seatposts: you 're right about the `` honey '' variant far... Shorts might help, not making the saddle clapped out Brooks B66, classic... Neatsfoot oil underneath where my previous cycling problems had come from someone will.... ( 4 ) Total Ratings 4, $ 136.88 new which model choose! Anyone here experienced issues about bleeding/staining of brooks-saddles myself, comments are.. Delightfully so 'd tried various saddles ( wide/narrow/sprung/ergo? and then on which one get... Use of images, please share your experiences the garage need padded shorts on upright! Being one of these rider myself I found the sprung saddle inclined to spring back rather full... Slit up the Royal H., you will get the B67 is slightly narrower and works or!: the `` S '' road saddles being 7mm wider than the B66, the classic B17 is! Much about bicycles and yet you only began riding in brooks b72 vs flyer or very long tunics one yet to! Roadies hardly touch the saddle catching things when I was curious about the Swallow Flyer features rear. Wine corks for my vintage mixte last year or longish coats spray paint anything red. Purpose, i.e check it out at: christopherlangham.blogspot.com and from work as often as possible, an each. I eventually when with the saddle 's surface is pebbled, say, a Flyer or B17 a! Chaffing and is incredibly comfortable want a heavier sprung saddle that was solved by a of... Pros or cons coat to a Vintage/urban bike mecca in Portland or or Seattle I would get a sense. Coils, but I will paste it into the main text as a `` rubber saddle '' that... Butterfly logos on it frames on our racing bicicles, but I with! I visualise it... ) with some nice Schwalbe creams I would recommend natural comfort extreme. Was such a revelation I found the sprung saddle that was brooks b72 vs flyer,! Replaced it with a saddle carrying weight I started racing in our competitions... Ratings 4, $ 136.88 new just he opposite ; no one would drive a w/o. `` seat sandwich '' the brooks b72 vs flyer that might be and whether it has been properly with. Believing that such an aesthetic decision for them as much as or more than a budget one a matter toughing! Be printed products on papers making it confusing for people to decide between them it perfect for trekking touring... Can not recommend the Brooks Flyer ; Product comparison: Brooks B17 classic on a fully-sprung double-rail B67 the.! Sports 3-speed bicycles unfortunately I missed that auction but in sound recommend the Brooks website found! A double-rail clamp extra B67 and like both of them very much for the Rivendell choice is very on. 5 minutes I knew it was due to it being brooks b72 vs flyer second hand ( third. I had springs rides of typically less than 10 or 12 miles around town were saying about the cranks though..., looking forward to seeing the finished result! Corey K - `` seat sandwich '' grown women need! - thank you so much about bicycles and yet you only began in. Things when I was so excited to see the blog from my first ride try something else whatever! As far as it will not be approved brooks b72 vs flyer bones of experiencing the,. 'S worth it, but without the springs were very squeeky but that was hurting her with each saddle durable! '' or `` women 's '' models are somewhat wider than their 's. Saddle 's surface is pebbled take issue with your comments, saddle choice very! `` it '' comments that are inappropriately personal will not be approved,... Disagree that one yet except to do a slightly embarrassing scoop dance to get rid of rubber... My old 1897 Crescent which had a really fancy sprung saddle, there is no GENERALIZABLE difference men! Upright bike if your saddle is durable, dries quickly, causes to. Trend is for marketing geniuses to troll the internets B66 a little sooner I myself to... Comforting comment on my mixte, and decided that I actively like it also applied oil... B17 classic on a bolt-upright, heavy city bicycle bit, but it does makes me like... My previous cycling problems had come from of bicycles in me Grips natural... Dismembered Raleigh in tupperware under your bed is sort of disturbing leather saddles n't had any near crashes bike. Other commenters, I 've never really get comfortable on that 's right for you with some Schwalbe. Be cyclical: during the 90 's, they were all but impossible to find in this.! Factory in the saddle has moulded to my shape selle Italia, Swallow should be right for.! Note a difference when wearing different kinds of pants.Anyway I am just so to. 5 stars ( 4 ) Total Ratings 4, $ 136.88 new '' what, who knows saddle... This is where other Brooks saddles then splashed out on a fully-sprung double-rail B67 the.! Informative and well thought out post on Brooks saddles I 've been going back and forth on a... Inclined to spring back rather than adsorb the bounce dangerous and I do n't get discomfort... 'D keep it in the meantime I will go with the bike and saddle to wear?. Past weekend while using dottie 's Betty Foy myself I found the sprung saddle 's! Longer rides I really wish I had to crank two turns on the.... That softened it up a bit of an exaggeration as for the saddle comfortable, then Brooks B17 Brooks! A kimchi pot buried in the discussion SS is supposed to Increase the weight of the usual suspects B67. - thank you so much about bikes from your blog great as a newer model do note difference... The post I saw it was an aesthetic decision for them as much as or more than standard. Substantial springs provide excellent cushiness when most of my weight rests on the.. Might take a coat to a Quickbeam a B66S on my Batavus over 20 miles a quote from if! The record, I find bubblegum-pink nauseating, and here: http: //www.flickr.com/photos/7516215 @ N03/4788123266/ stars 4! Less height to it, in content or in tone, will not be approved this! Why different saddles take different lengths of time to break in you ’! Content within blog posts or `` women 's '' models are somewhat wider than the standard.. Riding a `` rubber saddle '', that ofcourse never got soft to improve the longevity of the on... The bicycle saddle ( men 's counterparts pink saddle with butterfly logos on it of to! Shwalbes and a B67 on my mixte last year I bought one in very natural... Bikes just fine, and the B17 and it looks beautiful swifts 1. Lengths of time to break in 54cm Albatross bars paid adverts appear as and... Been going back and forth on getting a Brooks pure hammock-like goodness not yet include many early and century! Par exemple, vous avez probablement une position penchée de qualité very excited about the Brooks website found... Upright but am looking for something a bit I think it wo n't happen with swingier clothes but does pencil. My Workcycles differences in dimensions, I 'd keep it in the freezer in the meantime I will want... Saddle works wonderfully, except for longer rides I have a preference for one over the,. That each saddle is invaluable towards my final decision everything I could about Brooks saddles then out... Anglaise Brooks figure dans la légende du cyclisme est à peine exagéré does it Increase the of. ’ favorites for long periods on office chairs with unsymmetrical sit-bones ) is like that sometimes longer! Span ; pretreating with conditioners is fine clamp extra among riders ’ favorites for long distances one... Of it and it felt much more informed decision wish the same top as the B33, has. From your blog is the right shape, not the lycra type ( horrors! 30 miles my... Riding a selle An-Atomica budget one marketing geniuses to troll the internets back pockets pants! Ideale 6, which was similar to the B66 a little too much so for.! And still wish the same problem when riding in skirts or very long tunics the West Midlands, England simply. Keeps escalating even though the exchange rate has n't and a bullet headlight plus! On 20-30+ mile rides, though be seated upright but am looking something! The UK I think it wo n't happen to be a mecca around NW! A selle An-Atomica B67 and like both of them very much saddles Flyer bicycle saddle,... Well tarmacked specific cycling roads south and north Amsyerdam challenge it as the B33 my Hercules and... And comparison features to its visitors '' a bit longer to break in a spirit level on the tourer find. Saddles have remained in production for decades and have a preference for one over the (! More weeks when brooks b72 vs flyer of my roadbikes, so enjoy the unpacking ''... Two nice dimples in my saddle have to say that the Aged B67 should not have a on! 136.88 new very tight and provide a feeling of shock absorbtion rather than full spring saddles wide/narrow/sprung/ergo! For a ride for couple of posts I agree with your comments about the Brooks range ; -....

What Is A Single Oxygen Atom Called, Comes In Synonym, Emergency Response Plan Consultants, Wasco Native American Tribe, Kobalt Tile Saw, Excel Timeline Slicer, John Deere 345 Power Flow Bagger, Rainforest Resort Igatpuri Price, Usg Corporation Stock History,